Ward’s 10 Best Engines, Version 2.0

2012 Ward’s 10 Best Engines

Four of this year’s winning engines are 2.0L in size. With downsizing taking root, the 2.0L displacement soon will be as common as black in a Model T showroom.

An unmistakable trend emerged as WardsAuto editors cycled through 36 vehicles during evaluations for the 2012 Ward’s 10 Best Engines competition: Engines are getting smaller.

Not only are 4-cyl. engines ubiquitous and a lot more enjoyable to drive, they also are gravitating toward a universal displacement of 2.0L.

Yes, there are new 1.6L and 1.8L I-4s, but eight of 34 engines evaluated for 2012 displace 2.0L and four of them made this year’s list. Of all the trophies awarded over the course of 18 years of Ward’s 10 Best Engines, never before have that many engines of the same size made the cut.

The reasons for the convergence at 2.0L differ from auto maker to auto maker, but tax incentives in Europe and China make it worthwhile to stay under 2.0L. And auto makers have discovered 2.0L as the sweet spot for both power density and refinement.

Besides, an engine size that starts with “2” is psychologically more marketable than if it starts with “1” and is nearly as fuel-efficient.

This year’s 2.0L superstars – all of them new or significantly upgraded – hail from BMW, Ford, General Motors and Mazda. All use direct-injection, and three of them are turbocharged.

All four are among the most-sophisticated engines offered by their respective brands, and yet they are affordable, practical and efficient.

And all four powerplants arrive in a displacement that soon will be as common as black in a Model T showroom.

Filling out the 2012 list are four repeat winners from Audi (3.0L supercharged V-6), BMW (3.0L turbo I-6), Chrysler (3.6L V-6) and Ford (5.0L V-8), as well as two first-timers from Hyundai (1.6L I-4) and Nissan (3.5L V-6 hybrid).

To be eligible for the competition, engines must be all-new or improved and available in a regular-production, U.S.-specification model during first-quarter 2012. Vehicle base price is capped at $55,000.

WardsAutoeditors drive the vehicles in their routine commutes during October and November and score each based on power, technology, refinement and observed fuel economy.

The awards will be presented Jan. 11 at a ceremony during the North American International Auto Show in Detroit.

This year’s winners automatically are eligible for the 2013 competition.

tmurphy@wardsauto.com

Discuss this article 5

All of the ten best engins ought to be "high volumne" engines.

There should be a seperate catagory for the best "no cost" criteria.

With all the emphasis on fuel economy, why aren't the engines "Dyno Tested" . A Dyno test would reveal the REALLY BEST ENGINE, What are the HP/CU IN and BSFC of each engine?

You people are testing drive train packages as well as engine isolation systems and you are calling it best engines!!

By tomk1  on Jan 11, 2012

Thanks for your comments, but we pick the engines this way, without the use of a dyno, so the list will be more relevant to consumers. And "high volume" has not been a criteria because there are many instances when great engines were in vehicles that weren't very popular (e.g. Contour SVT, Mazda Millenia S). As for "no cost," it sounds like you're suggesting we have an unlimited category, with no price cap. From our perspective, a best engine should come automatically when absurd money is spent.

By Tom Murphy  on Jan 18, 2012

Ward's thought the Contour SVT D25 V6 was a great engine?

If that's the case, we can only hope for the same enthusiasm for the Focus/Fiesta ST powertrains

By is228979  on Jan 19, 2012

When the Focus ST comes to market, you can rest assured the Ward's editors will have a field day evaluating it for 10 Best Engines, with its 250-hp EcoBoost 4-cyl. Falling under the $55,000 price cap shouldn't be a problem. Word is, the ST should be in the competition this fall. Stay tuned.

By Tom Murphy  on Feb 2, 2012

I think I've heard under $30k, which would be ideal to give people another Ford option other than the Mustang for some power on wheels. Just try to stay objective while you are taking the rubber off the tires. Look forward to the review.

By is228979  on Feb 3, 2012

Please login or register to post comments

Related Resources

Navigation-system maker TomTom is offering downloads of celebrity voices (including some of these) to guide you on your route. Who would you like to have tell you where to go?

Data Center

There are a number of ways to find data on WardsAuto:

BROWSE : Explore the breadth of WardsAuto data by geography and data type.
SEARCH: Use keywords and filters to search all data.
Reference: View reference and non-time-series data.
Public Data: A collection of data tables available to non-subscribers.

A subscription is required to see locked content.
We also welcome requests for customized data.

Go to Data Center