More stories related to Auto Interiors Show DETROIT – What makes a best-in-class vehicle interior? Innovative design? The best fit and finish? The nicest materials?

Whatever it is, automotive journalists and industry insiders don't seem to agree on the criteria.

At the Auto Interiors show here , eight new '05 vehicles were awarded best-in-class honors: four European, three Detroit and one Asian brand.

A total of 81 automotive journalists from around the country picked the new Audi A4 and A6 as having the best interiors for popularly priced and premium cars, respectively, while the Honda Odyssey minivan and Ford's Land Rover LR3 SUV were rated best in popularly priced and premium truck categories.

Audi A4

Ford Mustang

Meanwhile, more than 900 automotive engineers, designers and executives involved with the development of interiors - but who don't work directly for any of the auto makers – voted for a completely different set of winners. They picked the Ford Mustang, Cadillac STS, Hummer H3 and the new Mercedes M-Class SUV for each of the four categories.

Consumers and sales numbers will provide the ultimate ruling, but the awards likely will fuel a growing debate between the automotive media and Detroit-based auto makers over how vehicles are evaluated.

General Motors Corp. Vice Chairman Bob Lutz frequently complains automotive journalists are biased towards foreign brands, while the media retorts that Detroit auto makers are too insular and are losing market share because they do not benchmark themselves against foreign brands enough.

Editors at Ward's, which presented this year's Interiors show, nominated the 23 models.

dwinter@primediabusiness.com