Special Report

Ward’s 10 Best Engines

Years ago, before the Toyota Prius earned respect in the market and while gasoline remained cheap, the debate was spirited among Ward’s editors deciding whether the hybrid-electric vehicle even belonged on the 10 Best Engines list.

The naysayers since have been silenced, vanquished by the runaway success of the Prius, which still managed nearly 130,000 U.S. sales through November in an awful market, according to Ward’s data.

This year, there was no debate about the all-new, third-generation Prius’ rightful place on the list. The marketplace has recognized the remarkable fuel efficiency the 1.8L DOHC I-4 hybrid can deliver when coupled with an electric motor, and so must we. The Prius also earned 10 Best Engines honors in 2001 and 2004.

“The Prius dishes up surprising power for a hybrid,” writes Editor-in-Chief Drew Winter on his Prius scoresheet. “It’s in a category all by itself.”

A full hybrid since its introduction in 2000, the new Prius benefits from a larger, more powerful 1.8L Atkinson-cycle, 4-cyl. that produces 98 hp. Combined with the electric motor, the new hybrid system generates a net 134 hp – 24 hp more than the previous car.

An electric water pump and new exhaust-gas recirculation system adds to the engine’s efficiency.

Toyota also delivers a clean-sheet overhaul of its patented Hybrid Synergy Drive technology that includes a lighter transaxle, a new direct cooling system for the inverter and new, more sophisticated regenerative braking system that feels much less grabby than previous generations.

Throttle tip-in is surprisingly smooth, and the power surges Ward’s editors used to notice on the highway are gone. The continuously variable transmission operates smoothly, and the transition from gas to electric and vice versa is seamless. At stop lights, the engine starts back up without a whiff of hesitation.

“This is the best execution of stop/start technology,” writes Ward’s Automotive Reports Editor Eric Mayne on his Prius scoresheet. “It’s very consistent.”

There are four ways to drive the Prius. Without changing any settings, the driver will be in the standard (or default) mode, which provides decent acceleration and pretty good mileage, too. Three other modes can be selected with switches on the center console.

Hyper-milers will want the most aggressive “EV” setting, which doesn’t last long before the gas engine switches on, even with a light foot. Slightly more enjoyable (but less fuel efficient than EV) is “ECO” mode, which stiffens accelerator-pedal resistance and makes it more difficult to tip into the throttle.

For merging onto the highway, the “Power” mode allows the engine to rev higher, sacrificing fuel economy somewhat.

But the “just right” setting requires no fiddling with buttons at all. One Ward’s editor seeking maximum mileage averaged 56.5 mpg (4.1 L/100 km), while others flogged the Prius and still managed better than 44 mpg (5.3 L/100 km), according to the vehicle trip computer.

It seems appropriate the first time the 10 Best Engines list has two hybrids on it, the Prius would be one of them.

tmurphy@wardsauto.com

Ward's 10 Best Engines is a copyright of Penton Media Inc. Commercial references to the program and/or awards are prohibited without prior permission of Ward's Automotive Group.