And If I Were the Car Czar

In keeping with the theme of “change” highlighted in the presidential election, I'd change some things in the automotive industry if I were the car czar.

Alfred Sloan wrote in his book, My Years with General Motors, “Whenever the automobile market shifts from a buyers' to a sellers,' or a sellers' to a buyers' market, a turbulence takes place in the industry, which disturbs both producers and dealers, and certain adjustments have to be made to meet the changing conditions.”

If I had a clean sheet of paper and ruled by imperial order, I would begin by having fewer same-brand dealerships selling more cars per location.

And we should limit the number of owners of same-brand stores in each market. The automotive retail world could be patterned after Saturn's original model or the Nissan Contiguous Market Ownership plan (i.e. the Mossy Automotive Group in San Diego).

Car-sales facilities, centralized-parts warehouses and satellite-service facilities would be strategically located in the community.

We would have clean utilitarian facilities for volume brands, not the expensive monuments many manufacturers require (and that many dealerships are no longer able to support).

Don't get me wrong, I think when you look at a dealership you should be able to tell immediately whether it's a Chevrolet, Toyota or Volkswagen store — and not just by the sign. But someone buying a Honda does not want to pay for facility amenities and sweeping architecture that provide no consumer value.

I like a latte every now and then and am willing to pay for it, but should my local dealership be required to offer it? Look, this business is becoming more of a commodity business than many of us would like to admit.

The quality and safety of all cars is good and getting better. I know style sells, but when they all look alike, you can bet cost will win out. The future in this business is to drive out cost. That means cost at the raw-materials level, supplier level, manufacturer level and, yes, the dealer level.

How do we do that at the dealer level?

In 1958, Martin H. Bury wrote in his book, The Automobile Dealer, “All factories are selfish. They want prestige, position and profit. To achieve these objectives, they must sell automobiles. The only customers they have are their dealers.

“And dealers will buy only as many cars as they can sell — and sell profitably. So the factories pursue a never-ending search for methods by which the dealers will sell more cars and for procedures by which the dealers will earn more profit. Is that bad?”

Seems to me, some manufacturers have changed from helping dealers make more money to hurting the dealers' profitability. That's a change in the wrong direction.

Don Ray is a CPA and Senior Vice President at AutoStar, a leading provider of long-term capital for auto dealers. He may be reached at 901-907-0134 and [email protected].

Questions or comments about this column? Send us an e-mail at [email protected].