Editor's note: This story is part of the WardsAuto digital archive, which may include content that was first published in print, or in different web layouts.
Ward’s 10 Best Engines had several big firsts this year. The first fuel-cell was one, but 2015 also marks the first time two 3-cyl. engines make the list.
Historically, 3-cyl. engines were something you were forced to drive by economic necessity, not something you actually wanted under the hood. However, we’re now seeing a new generation of small boosted 3-cyl. mills that still are base engines, but are incredibly powerful for their size, tout lots of advanced technology and are a lot of fun to drive.
BMW’s turbocharged 1.5L B38 in its Mini brand certainly falls into this category. And even though the Mini Cooper Hardtop starts at about $20,000, we are tempted to call the 1.5L a premium 3-cyl., because Ford’s 1.0L EcoBoost – the other 3-cyl. on the 2015 list – is available in a Fiesta model starting at under $16,000.
The B38 offers the same features as BMW engines on much more expensive vehicles, such as the latest-generation gasoline direct-injection system and Valvetronic variable valve control.
And this engine is destined for wide use in BMW-brand cars such as the 218i Coupe in markets outside the U.S.
It also is a major improvement over its 4-cyl. predecessor, the very competent 1.6L Prince engine, which BMW jointly developed with PSA Peugeot Citroen. The entry-level Mini’s torque increases by 42%, and 0-60 mph (97 km/h) acceleration is chopped by 2.3 seconds compared with the Prince. Fuel efficiency increases as much as 8%.
Even though the engine seems designed more for performance than efficiency, every juror logged at least 30 mpg (7.8 L/100 km) in mixed daily driving. Official EPA numbers are 29/40 mpg (8.1-5.9 L/100 km) city/highway and 33 mpg (7.1 L/100 km) combined.
What most impresses WardsAuto editors is the small engine’s peppy 162 lb.-ft. (220 Nm) of torque and its deep, resonant growl during acceleration, which gives it a lot of personality. In some ways it sounds similar to BMW’s iconic 3.0L I-6, in part because it is essentially that engine split in half.
BMW says the sound frequency of a 3-cyl. engine increases 50% faster than that of a 4-cyl., and that gives the engine its sporty, more emotional exhaust note. Some call it “vivacious.”
One editor says he couldn’t imagine driving a Mini with any other engine. As the number of very good 2.0L 4-cyl. turbos continues to grow, the 3-pots clearly are starting to stand out. “With a starting price just under $21,000, the Mini Cooper Hardtop with the 3-cyl. engine is the smart choice,” says WardsAuto editor Tom Murphy.
In the world of motorcycles, “triples” are beloved for their compactness, efficiency and distinct exhaust note. It’s very possible a new generation of automotive 3-cyl. engines may develop a similar following for exactly the same reasons.
